Skip to content
footballingworld

footballingworld

Make the Rules

Primary Menu
  • Sport Equipment
  • Sport Center
  • News Sport
  • Basketball
  • Football
  • About Us
    • Advertise Here
    • Contact Us
    • Privacy Policy
    • Sitemap
  • Home
  • Lawyer: Doctors who sued CHCC, RHC have constitutional right to jury trial | News
  • Sport Center

Lawyer: Doctors who sued CHCC, RHC have constitutional right to jury trial | News

By Elsie A. Dotson 2 years ago

DOCTORS Francois Claassens and James Toskas want their case heard by an impartial jury, said attorney Tiberius Mocanu who represents them in their lawsuit against the Commonwealth Healthcare Corporation and the Rota Health Center.

“The Government wants to protect its coffers and it thinks that it will have a better chance doing so with this court as the trier of fact than a jury. Nevertheless, the Government can rest assured that the downside liability it faces is identical with this court or with a jury. Conversely, Dr. Toskas and Dr. Claassens have a constitutional right to a jury trial; a right this Court has previously affirmed. It should again,” said Mocanu, in response to the Office of the Attorney General’s objection to the demand of the doctors to hold a jury trial on Rota.

In 2017, Claassens and Toskas sued RHC and CHCC for compensation for work performed beyond their normal schedules, claiming breach of contract and quantum meruit, a Latin term meaning “what one has earned” or “reasonable value of services.”

The doctors are alleging that CHCC and RHC failed to pay them for administrative leave accruement totaling $635,187. In May 2018, Superior Court Associate Judge Joseph N. Camacho dismissed their claims, saying that no one authorized Claassens and Toskas to obtain additional compensation for working extra hours.

But the doctors appealed and on Aug. 2, 2021, the CNMI Supreme Court reversed the trial court’s ruling and remanded the lawsuit for further proceedings.

On Jan. 7, 2022, CHCC and RHC, through Assistant Attorneys General John P. Lowrey and Stephen T. Anson, filed a notice objecting to the plaintiffs’ demand for a jury trial.

“Defendants have not consented to the jury trial demand, and instead conveyed to the Court during the January 4, 2022 status conference that the dispute could be resolved through dispositive motions following the conclusion of discovery,” the government lawyers said.

To clear up any confusion, they added, “defendants file this instant notice to clarify the record that defendants object to plaintiffs’ jury trial demand and that plaintiffs otherwise lack a right to a jury trial for their claims against the Commonwealth.”

According to the government lawyers, “A jury trial is otherwise unavailable to the plaintiffs asserting their specific claims against CHCC under the Commonwealth Code.”

They added, “Claims concerning an express or implied contract with the Commonwealth government are one of the types of actions specified in 7 CMC § 2251(b). 7 CMC § 2251 applies to CHCC as a public corporation to the same extent it applies to the Commonwealth itself 7 CMC § 2211. 7 CMC § 2253 further confirms that all actions brought against the Commonwealth ‘shall be tried by the court without a jury.’”

The Commonwealth “may waive the provisions of 7 CMC § 2253 in a particular case, and may demand a trial by jury to the same extent as a private party would be entitled to do so,” they said.

However, in this instance, “defendants do not waive the certain foregoing provisions of the Commonwealth Code and do not consent to a jury trial,” the government lawyers said.

“To the extent this dispute cannot be resolved through a dispositive motion, it must be resolved at a bench trial instead of a jury trial,” they added.

But in his opposition to the government’s objection to his client’s jury trial demand, Mocanu said this court has found the Government Liability Act’s provision prohibiting a jury trial unconstitutional.

“The court reasoned that purely economic reasons such as protecting the Commonwealth’s coffers and protecting public employment were not compelling enough reasons to withstand a strict scrutiny review. As such the court held that the substitution provision, the prohibition on punitive damages, and the restriction on jury trials were all unconstitutional,” Mocanu said.

The government argued that the Commonwealth has an interest against runaway jury verdicts, which could subject the government to unlimited liability, he said.

“However, the narrow interest of protecting the Commonwealth’s coffers is not protected simply by eliminating jury trials, it is protected by damage caps, prohibiting punitive damages, and attorney’s fees. Here, Dr. Toskas and Dr. Claassens are not claiming punitive damages and did not ask for attorney fees. Instead, all they are asking for is that their case be heard by an impartial jury.”

The government’s stated interest, whether examined under rational basis or strict scrutiny, is moot as the jury can award no more money than this court, Mocanu said.

“The damage caps applicable to this case already solve for the Government’s stated interest in the GLA [or the Government Liability Act]. Having this case tried by this court, as opposed to a jury, has no impact on the Government’s coffers,” the lawyer added.

Tags: ""Sports"" Crop Top, After School Sports Santa Clarita, Bryn Maur Sports Drinks, Cbs V Cbs Sports, Fighting Sports Are Boring, Gm Sports San Jose California, Graphic Sports Job, Heavenly Sports Rental Seasonal, Kids Sports Prescription Sunglasses, Mini Sports Collection 3ds, Mio Michigan Outdoor Sports, Nbc Sports App Contact, Nbc Sports Executives Bios, Nbc Sports Group Interview, Nbc Sports Philly Kate Smith, News Sentinel Fort Wayne Sports, Northampton Girls Sports, Prolinks Sports The Woodlands, Robbers Sports Logo, Robert Blum Sports, Scott Boras Sports Illustrated, Seinfeld You Gotta Love Sports, Site:Cnusports.Com Cnu Sports, Small Business Journal Sports, Snow Hill High School Sports, Souness Pogba Sky Sports, Sports Bar Beaumont Ca, Sports Bar Near Sfo Airport, Sports Club Logo Ideas, Sports Direct Canterbury Opening Times, Sports Highlights Show, Sports Jackets Guide, Sports Jackets Manufacturers, Sports Lawyer, Sports Logos Inspiration, Sports Marketing Intern Indianapolis, Sports Massage Therapist Warwick Ri, Sports Netowrking Events Seattle, Sports Sheets Under Bed, Sports Store Tukwila, Sports Teams Psyches, The Wave At Sports Events, Udel Sports Management Internships, Umass Sports Physio, Unh, Utah High School Sports Facebook, Want To Open Sports Bar, Watch Verizon Fios Anywhere Sports, What Is Spectator Sports Accounting, Why I Dont Like Sports, Wild Animal Sports Day Unlisted

Continue Reading

Previous Paralympics close to end Asia’s run at center of world sport
Next Two-sport standout earns the top athletic honor for Shakopee | Shakopee Sports
October 2023
M T W T F S S
 1
2345678
9101112131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
3031  
« Sep    

Archives

Recent Posts

  • Arsenal warned January move for star will cost them more than the £87m Man Utd spent on Antony
  • Chart Shows Why Sean Murphy Needs To Leave Oakland
  • First mass-produced vehicle to be developed in Scotland in 40 years will be an Off-roader
  • All you need to know about LaMelo Ball rookie cards including prices and best places to buy
  • What Pros Wear: 9 Hottest Bats in the World Series

BL

Tags

17 D1 St Johns Sports 2018 Pontiac Sports Cars Acady Sports Knoxville Tn Arizona High School Scholastic Sports Body Tests For Sports Bowling Shoes At Academy Sports Brazzers Sports Bra Blonde Burlingame Rec Center Bis Sports Champagne Sports Resort Winterton Christina Crockett Vice Sports Cloverdale Physiotherapy And Sports Clinic Clubhouse Sports Bar And Grill Diane Richardson Northway Sports Mn Emerald Isle Nc Water Sports Equine Sports Management Espn Classic Sports Expert Sports Free Picks F150 Outdoor Sports Fillmore Youth Sports Ford'S Real Hottest Sports Car Fort Dodge Rogers Sports Complex Four Points By Kc Sports Hamilton Southeastern Schools Sports Avaolbe High School Sports Standings Jd Sports Mens Trainers Sale Jenna Marbles Sports Center Justice Convertible Strap Sports Bra Karin Sultan Sports Gta 5 Keeping Up With Sports Live Sports Only Streaming Services Manhattanville College Sports Division Michael Irvin Sports Illustrated Midco Sioux Falls Sports Channel Most Unbiased Sports Colum Motor Sports Channels In Us Nos Center Sports Center One World Sports Rcn Pays Big Sports Betting Percentageof Sports Injuries Performance Sports Group Products Pickle Juice Sport Academy Sports Playing Sports Best When Angry Prime Sports Nederland Public Water Sports In Austin Samsung Galaxy S4 Sports Cases

getlinko

footballingworld.com | Magazine 7 by AF themes.

WhatsApp us